2-Bedroom Apartments for Rent in Prospect Heights Under $5,000

Prospect Heights borders Prospect Park and is home to the Barclays Center. It's got a nice mix of restaurants, brownstones, and a calmer vibe than neighboring areas. The 2/3/B/Q trains are convenient.

102 listings available — updated May 18, 2026, refreshed every 3 hours

Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

787 Washington Avenue TOP FLOOR

$4,400/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

931 Carroll Street C1007

$4,700/mo
2 bed2 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

1072 Dean Street 1

$3,000/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

1134 Fulton Street 6O

$3,850/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

236 Underhill Avenue 2

$4,500/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsMgmt Co.
StreetEasy
Verified

750 Washington Avenue 1LR

$3,400/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

135 Lefferts Place 3A

$4,600/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

435 Grand Avenue 2E

$4,000/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsMgmt Co.
StreetEasy
Verified

429 Lincoln Place A2

$4,500/mo
2 bed2 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

597 Grand Avenue 1C

$4,495/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

876 Bergen Street 6F

$3,900/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

931 Carroll Street C1008

$4,650/mo
2 bed2 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

1040 Dean Street 502

$4,088/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsMgmt Co.
StreetEasy
Verified

429 Lincoln Place C3

$4,000/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

1051 Pacific Street 505N

$5,000/mo
2 bed2 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

159 Eastern Parkway 4A

$4,000/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

319 Lincoln Place 2H

$3,995/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

931 Carroll Street C801

$4,900/mo
2 bed2 bath
View listing
Listing photo 1 of 5
Prospect HeightsLandlord
Craigslist

Prospect Heights - Franklin Av (2)(3)(4)(5)(S

$3,600/mo
2 bed
View listing
Listing photo
Prospect HeightsBroker
StreetEasy
Verified

531 Bergen Street 2L

$5,000/mo
2 bed1 bath
View listing

Stop messaging landlords one by one

Sign up for free to see full details and we'll automatically reach out to landlords on your behalf. No payment info required.

100% freeNo credit card10+ listing sourcesAutomated outreach

Frequently asked

How many 2-bedroom apartments are available in Prospect Heights right now?

As of May 18, 2026, Rentomatics tracks 102 2-bedroom apartments for rent in Prospect Heights under $5,000/month. Listings refresh every 3 hours from StreetEasy, Craigslist, Nooklyn, Zumper, CityRealty, and more.

What is the rent for a 2-bedroom in Prospect Heights?

Among current Rentomatics listings, 2-bedroom apartments in Prospect Heights start at $2,800/month, with an average of $4,102 and a median of $4,200/month. Prices reflect 102 active listings updated May 18, 2026.

How often are Rentomatics listings updated?

Rentomatics refreshes listings every 3 hours by scraping StreetEasy, Craigslist, Nooklyn, Zumper, CityRealty, Compass, Douglas Elliman, and OpenIgloo. Stale listings are removed within 5 days of last sighting.

Does Rentomatics show broker fees?

Yes. Every Rentomatics listing displays whether a broker fee applies, and users can filter to show only no-fee apartments. Broker fee status is inferred from listing source metadata when not explicitly provided.

What is Prospect Heights like?

Prospect Heights borders Prospect Park and is home to the Barclays Center. It's got a nice mix of restaurants, brownstones, and a calmer vibe than neighboring areas. The 2/3/B/Q trains are convenient.

Explore nearby